Choosing hiring software · 5 min read
ATS selection checklist
A checklist of the criteria that matter when you compare applicant tracking systems. Mark each item as must have, should have or not needed, then score every option against the same list.
How to use this checklist
This checklist is meant to be copied into a scoring sheet, printed for a demo or shared with the people helping you decide. It does not tell you which items matter most. That depends on how you hire. If you have not yet worked out your requirements, read how to choose an applicant tracking system first.
- Go through each item and mark it must have, should have or not needed.
- Remove the items marked not needed so the list stays short.
- Score each system from 1 to 5 on every remaining item, based on what you saw in a demo or trial, not on what the sales material says.
- Give must-have items double weight when you add up the totals.
- Rule out any system that fails a must-have, whatever its total.
Fill in the scores right after each demo while the details are fresh. Our list of hiring software demo questions helps make sure each item actually gets tested rather than described.
Job posting and sourcing
- Create a job from a template, with your own fields and requirements.
- Share an apply link that works on any device without forcing applicants to create an account.
- Embed open roles on your careers page so the list updates automatically.
- Reach the job boards you use, or export the job in a format they accept.
- Upload CVs in bulk, for example after a careers fair or from an agency.
- Search past applicants before you post a new role.
- Record where each applicant came from, so you can see which sources work.
- Let applicants apply in a few minutes, with a clear privacy notice.
Past applicants are often the quickest source of good people for a new role. If that matters to you, see our guide to building a talent pool and weigh the search item accordingly.
Screening and shortlisting
- Pull the key skills and requirements out of the job description, and let you edit them.
- Compare every CV against the same requirements, not just a keyword match.
- Show why an applicant scored the way they did, so a person can check the reasoning.
- Rank applicants while leaving the final decision with a person.
- Add knockout questions, such as right to work or a required licence, where relevant.
- Filter and sort applicants by stage, score, source and date.
- Flag duplicate applications.
- Send rejection messages in bulk, using a respectful template.
Spark Careers Enterprise pulls the skills out of the job description and scores each CV against them, listing matched and missing skills with a short summary, then ranks applicants for your review.
Clear, consistent criteria matter more than any feature here. For the method behind this, see how to screen CVs against requirements.
Pipeline and collaboration
- Set up stages that match your process, with different stages per role if needed.
- Move applicants between stages quickly, one at a time or in groups.
- Keep notes, CVs, messages and feedback together on the applicant's record.
- Let interviewers submit structured feedback or a scorecard.
- Notify colleagues when their input is needed, and remind them when it is late.
- Give each user a role that controls what they can see and do.
- Give hiring managers a simple view they can use without training.
- Support outside recruiters or agencies, with access limited to their own roles.
Test this section with a hiring manager, not just a recruiter. Ask them to find an applicant, read the notes and leave feedback without help. If they need a walkthrough to do that, most of your managers will skip the system and send feedback by email instead.
Interviews and communication
- Let applicants pick an interview time from a booking link.
- Connect to interviewers' calendars to avoid double bookings.
- Run live video interviews, or recorded ones that applicants complete in their own time.
- Send editable email templates for invites, reminders, updates and rejections.
- Keep a record of every message sent to an applicant.
- Track offers from draft to accepted or declined.
Scheduling is where many hiring processes lose days. When you score these items, book a test interview as if you were an applicant, on a phone, and count the steps. Then check what the interviewer receives and whether the time appears in their calendar.
Reporting, data and security
- Show basic metrics: applicants per role, time in each stage, time to hire and source of hire.
- Filter reports by role, team, location and date.
- Export applicant and job data to CSV or a similar format at any time.
- Record applicant consent and show a privacy notice.
- Set how long applicant data is kept, and delete it on request.
- Control access by role, and log who changed what.
- Explain clearly where data is stored and how it is backed up.
- Support the employment and data protection rules where you hire.
Do not take export and deletion on trust. During a trial, export a full set of applicant records and open the file to see what is actually included. Then delete a test applicant and confirm the record is gone from searches and reports, not just hidden from view.
Cost, setup and support
- A clear pricing model, such as per user, per job or a flat fee, in writing.
- A known cost for adding users or opening more roles.
- Setup and training either included or priced up front.
- A realistic setup time for your number of roles and users.
- Support channels, hours and response times stated in writing.
- Contract length, notice period and renewal terms you can accept.
- A trial or sandbox where you can test with a real role.
- A full data export if you leave, with no extra fee.
Once every option is scored, compare the top two side by side and ask the people who tested them which one they would rather use every day. The scores narrow the field. Everyday ease of use usually settles it.
Your next hire, start to finish, in one place.
Free workspace. No card. Full scoring free for 7 days.