Interviews · 5 min read
How to give candidates feedback
Clear, prompt feedback helps candidates and protects your reputation as an employer. This guide covers what to say at each stage, what to leave out and example messages you can adapt.
Why feedback is worth the effort
Most people who apply for a role will not get it. How you tell them shapes what they think of you, whether they apply again and what they say to others. A short, honest message also saves your team time, because candidates who hear nothing tend to chase.
Feedback does not need to be long. It needs to be prompt, specific where it can be, and consistent. The simplest way to achieve this is to decide in advance what each candidate will receive at each stage, and who will send it.
Match the feedback to the stage
- Not shortlisted after applying: a short, polite message soon after the decision. Personal feedback is not expected at this stage, but a clear answer is.
- Rejected after a screening call: a brief message with one or two specific points if you can give them, and an offer to consider them for future roles if that offer is genuine.
- Rejected after interviews: specific feedback tied to the criteria for the role. Offer a short call if they would like more detail.
- Final stage runners up: a phone call from the hiring manager or recruiter, with clear feedback and, where it is true, an invitation to stay in touch.
Whatever the stage, tell candidates as soon as a decision is made. Silence is worse than a short no. If a decision is delayed, say so and give a new date.
Be honest about what you can offer. If your team cannot give personal feedback to everyone who applied, say so in the job ad or the first message, and explain that candidates who reach interview will hear specific points. Setting the expectation early prevents disappointment and reduces follow-up emails.
What good feedback looks like
Good feedback comes from the evidence you gathered, not from a general impression. If you ran a structured interview and used an interview scorecard, you already have what you need: criteria, scores and notes on what the candidate said.
- Tie it to the job. "The role needs someone who can build financial models independently, and your examples focused on reviewing models others had built."
- Be specific. Point to an answer or a task, not a personality trait.
- Keep it short. Two or three points is enough. A long list feels like a pile on.
- Include a strength. Most candidates who reach interview did something well. Say what it was.
- Make it useful. Where you can, say what would have made the difference.
In Spark Careers Enterprise, interview notes and team feedback are kept against each applicant on the pipeline board, so the person writing feedback can see the evidence from every stage in one place.
What to avoid
- Comparisons with named or described candidates. Say what the role needed, not that someone else was better.
- Comments on appearance, age, family, health, religion, background or any similar personal characteristic. These are not relevant to the job and can create legal risk. Check the employment and data protection rules where you hire.
- Vague phrases such as "not the right fit" with nothing behind them.
- Promises you cannot keep, such as "we will definitely contact you about the next role".
- Debating the decision. Feedback explains the decision. It does not reopen it.
If you are not sure whether a point is fair to share, ask whether it relates directly to a written requirement for the role. If it does not, leave it out. Our guide to reducing bias in hiring explains why this test matters well beyond feedback.
Example messages you can adapt
After an application that was not shortlisted:
"Thank you for applying for the Data Analyst role. We have reviewed all applications and will not be taking yours further this time. For this role we focused on candidates with experience building dashboards for business teams. We appreciate your interest and wish you well in your search."
After interviews:
"Thank you for your time interviewing for the Project Manager role. We have decided not to offer you the position. The panel valued your clear planning example and the way you explained risks to stakeholders. The main gap against the role was experience managing budgets directly, which is a large part of this job. If you would like to talk this through, I am happy to arrange a short call."
Keep a small set of templates like these for each stage. Then add one or two specific sentences from the scorecard for candidates who reached interview. The template keeps the tone consistent. The specific sentences make it worth reading.
Make it part of the process
- Decide who sends feedback for each role, usually the recruiter or the hiring manager.
- Agree the timing, for example within two working days of the final decision.
- Use scorecard notes as the source, so the feedback matches the evidence.
- Send the message, and record that it was sent.
- If a candidate replies with questions, answer once, kindly and briefly, then close the conversation.
Some candidates will disagree with the decision, and a few will be upset. Thank them for their reply, restate the main reason in one or two sentences, and avoid getting drawn into a back and forth about individual answers. If they raise a concern about how they were treated, pass it to the right person in HR and reply to confirm it will be looked at. Never change the reason you gave to soften a difficult conversation, since inconsistent explanations cause more harm than a clear one.
Candidates you turn down today may be right for a role next year. Ending on good terms, and keeping their details with their consent, makes it much easier to come back to them later.
Candidate feedback checklist
- Every candidate gets a clear answer, even if it is brief
- Feedback depth matches the stage the candidate reached
- Points tied to the role's written criteria
- At least one genuine strength for interviewed candidates
- No comparisons, no personal characteristics, no promises
- One named owner and a set timing for each role
- Templates ready for each stage
- Feedback sent and recorded
Your next hire, start to finish, in one place.
Free workspace. No card. Full scoring free for 7 days.