Interviews · 5 min read
How to run structured interviews
A structured interview asks every candidate the same planned questions and scores the answers against the same criteria. This guide walks through the method from defining the job to making the final decision.
What a structured interview is
A structured interview is one where every candidate for a role answers the same core questions, in the same order, and is scored against the same criteria. The interviewers agree what a good answer looks like before they meet anyone. The result is a set of scores you can compare fairly, rather than a set of impressions that depend on who ran the conversation and how it happened to go.
Unstructured interviews feel natural, but they tend to reward candidates who are easy to talk to or who share the interviewer's background. They also make it hard to explain later why one person was chosen over another. Structure does not mean a cold or robotic conversation. It means the important parts are planned, so the time is spent on evidence instead of small talk.
The method has five steps: decide what the job needs, write the questions, agree how to score, run every interview the same way, and decide together on the evidence.
Step 1: Decide what the job really needs
Start from the job, not the questions. Read the job description and list the four to six things that will decide whether someone succeeds in the first year. Mix skills, knowledge and behaviours. If the description is vague, fix it first. Our job description templates are a useful starting point.
For each item, write one sentence that describes what it looks like in practice. For example, for a customer service role:
- Problem solving: finds the real cause of a customer's issue and resolves it without passing it around the team.
- Written communication: writes replies that are clear, correct and friendly on the first attempt.
- Composure: stays calm and polite when a customer is angry or rude.
- Product learning: picks up new products and policies quickly and applies them accurately.
Keep the list short. If you try to assess ten things in a 45 minute interview, you will assess none of them well. Anything that can be checked more reliably another way, such as a certification or a typing test, should be checked that way and left out of the interview.
Step 2: Write the questions
Write one or two main questions for each item on your list. Two types of question work well.
- Behavioural questions ask about real past events: "Tell me about a time a customer was unhappy with a decision you could not change. What did you do?" Past behaviour in similar situations is good evidence of future behaviour.
- Situational questions describe a realistic scenario and ask how the candidate would handle it: "A customer emails three times in an hour about a late delivery. Walk me through how you would respond." These suit candidates with less work history.
Add a small set of planned follow-up questions for each main question, such as "What was the result?" or "What would you do differently next time?" Interviewers can use these to get more detail, but they should not invent new topics on the spot. If you need ideas, the interview question bank has role specific questions you can adapt.
Test the questions on a colleague who does the job well. If they struggle to understand a question, or if every possible answer sounds equally good, rewrite it.
Step 3: Agree how answers will be scored
Before the first interview, agree a rating scale and describe what a weak, adequate and strong answer looks like for each question. A simple one to four scale avoids a safe middle score. Write the descriptions in terms of evidence: what the candidate did, how specific they were, and what the result was.
Every interviewer should score each answer on their own, during or straight after the interview, before talking to anyone else. This one habit removes a lot of groupthink. The detail of how to lay out the scoring sheet itself is covered in our guide on how to build an interview scorecard.
Step 4: Run every interview the same way
- Open with the same short introduction: who is in the room, how long the interview lasts, and that you will take notes.
- Ask the main questions in the agreed order. Use only the planned follow-up questions to draw out detail.
- Take notes on what the candidate actually said, not your opinion of it. "Rebuilt the refund process, complaints fell" is useful. "Seemed sharp" is not.
- Keep to time for each question so the last topics are not rushed.
- Leave the same amount of time at the end for the candidate's own questions.
- Close by explaining the next steps and when they will hear back.
Small adjustments are fine. You can rephrase a question a candidate did not understand, and you should make reasonable adjustments for disability or access needs. What you should avoid is going off script in ways that give one candidate a harder or easier interview than another.
Step 5: Make the decision together
Hold a short debrief once all interviewers have submitted their scores. Go through the criteria one at a time. Where scores differ, ask each person to point to the evidence in their notes. Often the gap closes once people compare what they actually heard.
Decide on the evidence, not on overall feeling. If the team keeps wanting to overrule the scores, that is a sign the criteria or questions need work before the next round. Write down the reasons for the decision while they are fresh. More on keeping decisions fair is in our guide on reducing bias in hiring. In Spark Careers Enterprise, each applicant moves through a pipeline board where interviewers add notes and team feedback at each stage, so everyone's input sits in one place for the debrief.
Structured interview checklist
- Four to six criteria taken from the job, each described in one sentence
- One or two main questions per criterion, tested on a colleague
- Planned follow-up questions, with no improvised topics
- A rating scale with written examples of weak, adequate and strong answers
- The same introduction, order and timing for every candidate
- Notes that record evidence, not opinions
- Independent scores submitted before the debrief
- A decision based on the scores, with the reasons written down
Your next hire, start to finish, in one place.
Free workspace. No card. Full scoring free for 7 days.