Process and pipeline · 5 min read
Working with hiring managers
The best hires come from searches where the recruiter and hiring manager work as one team. This guide covers the intake meeting, shared criteria, agreed timings and how to settle disagreements with evidence.
A shared search, not a handover
The best hires come from searches where the recruiter and the hiring manager act as one team. The hiring manager knows the work and the team. The recruiter knows the market, the process and how to assess people fairly. When either side treats the search as the other side's job, things slip: the brief is vague, feedback is slow, good applicants drop out and the final hire is a compromise.
Working well together does not depend on personalities. It depends on a few habits agreed at the start and kept to. This guide covers those habits, whether you are an in-house recruiter, an HR generalist who also recruits or an agency recruiter working for a client.
Run a real intake meeting
The intake meeting is the most important hour of the search. Book it as soon as the role is approved, keep it to the hiring manager and recruiter, plus one interviewer if useful, and leave with written answers to these questions.
- Why is this role open, and what must the person achieve in their first months?
- What are the must-have requirements, and which items on the current job description are only nice to have?
- What would make you reject an applicant who looks strong on paper?
- Who does this role well today, inside or outside the team, and what makes them good at it?
- What is the pay range, and how much flexibility is there?
- What interview stages will we run, who sits on each and what does each stage assess?
- How quickly can you review shortlists and give interview feedback?
If the job description is weak, fix it in this meeting. Our job description templates give a starting point for 40 roles. Send a one-page summary of the intake to the hiring manager the same day and ask them to confirm it in writing.
Agree the criteria before you see anyone
Agreeing what good looks like before anyone reviews applicants is one of the best protections against moving goalposts and personal bias. Turn the must-haves from the intake into a short scorecard, with a clear description of what a strong, an acceptable and a weak answer looks like for each.
Use the same criteria for CV screening, interviews and the final decision. If the hiring manager wants to change them partway through, that is allowed, but make it an explicit decision, write it down and re-check earlier applicants against the new criteria. The guides on the interview scorecard and structured interviews show how to build and use one.
Set service levels on both sides
Slow feedback is one of the main ways good applicants are lost. Agree simple, written timings for both sides at the intake meeting.
- The recruiter sends a first shortlist within an agreed number of working days.
- The hiring manager reviews each shortlist within an agreed number of working days.
- Interviewers submit their scorecards on the day of the interview, before talking to each other.
- The debrief happens within an agreed number of days of the last interview.
- Offers are approved within an agreed time after the decision.
Then check them. A brief weekly update from the recruiter, showing where each applicant stands and what is waiting on whom, keeps the search moving without long meetings. In Spark Careers Enterprise, the hiring manager and recruiter work from the same pipeline board, with notes and team feedback on each applicant, so status updates do not have to travel by email.
Give and ask for useful feedback
Feedback in both directions should be specific and tied to the agreed criteria.
- From hiring manager to recruiter: instead of "not quite right", say which must-have was missing or weak and what evidence showed it. This tells the recruiter how to adjust the search.
- From recruiter to hiring manager: if the shortlist is thin, share what you are seeing in the market, such as pay expectations or scarce skills, and propose a specific change to the brief or the pay range.
- After the first shortlist, hold a short calibration call. Review a few CVs together and agree why each one is a yes or a no. This lines up judgment early, before interviews start.
- Close the loop with applicants. Agree who tells each applicant the outcome, and by when.
Keep feedback in writing where you can, even when it starts as a corridor conversation. A short note on the applicant record, linked to the criteria, means the next person who looks at the search understands why decisions were made. It also protects the organisation if a decision is ever questioned later.
Handle disagreements and decisions
Disagreements are normal. Settle them with evidence, not seniority.
- Go back to the agreed criteria and the scorecards. Ask each person to point to the evidence behind their view.
- If the evidence is mixed, name what is missing and decide how to get it, such as a work sample, a follow-up conversation or a reference.
- If the criteria themselves are in question, pause and agree any change explicitly before continuing.
- The hiring manager usually makes the final call. The recruiter's job is to make sure it rests on the agreed evidence and is recorded with a reason.
Over time, review how searches went with each hiring manager. Time in each stage, offer acceptance and the hiring manager's rating of the hire after a few months are good starting points. See hiring metrics that matter for how to calculate them.
Checklist for every search
- The intake meeting is held and the summary confirmed in writing.
- Must-haves and nice-to-haves are agreed.
- A scorecard is agreed before any applicant is reviewed.
- Feedback timings are agreed for both sides.
- A weekly status update is in place.
- A calibration call follows the first shortlist.
- Any change to the criteria is made explicitly and recorded.
- The final decision is recorded with the reason.
Your next hire, start to finish, in one place.
Free workspace. No card. Full scoring free for 7 days.