Process and pipeline · 5 min read

Recruiting agency workflows

Agencies run many searches for many clients at once, so a shared workflow keeps quality steady. This guide sets out each step from the first client call to the weeks after a placement.

Why agencies need a written workflow

A recruiting agency runs many searches for many clients at once. Each client has its own roles, its own hiring managers and its own way of giving feedback. Without a shared workflow, every recruiter works differently, candidates get submitted twice and clients hear about progress only when they chase. A written workflow, the same for every search, keeps quality steady as the desk gets busier and lets a colleague pick up a search when someone is away.

The workflow below runs from the first client conversation to the weeks after a placement. Adjust the detail to your contracts and specialism, but keep the sequence.

Take a proper job order

Many failed searches go wrong at intake. A short call where the client reads out a job description is not an intake. Book a proper conversation with the hiring manager, not only HR or procurement, and come away with a written job order that covers the following.

  • The role, why it is open and what success looks like in the first months.
  • Must-have requirements and nice-to-haves, kept separate.
  • Pay range, benefits, location and working pattern.
  • The client's interview stages, who sits on each and how long each takes.
  • Who gives feedback on submissions, and within how many working days.
  • Terms: fee, exclusivity, replacement period and any companies you have agreed not to approach.
  • What the client has already tried, and whether there are internal candidates.

Send the job order back to the client in writing and ask them to confirm it. It becomes the brief you screen against and the reference point if expectations shift later. The guide on working with hiring managers covers intake questions in more depth.

Source and screen against the brief

  1. Search your own database first. Past candidates you already know are faster to place and easier to judge.
  2. Then advertise and approach. Write the ad from the job order, not from the client's internal job description.
  3. Screen every CV against the must-haves in the job order. Record why each person moved forward or did not.
  4. Hold a screening call with each candidate you plan to submit. Confirm interest, pay expectations, notice period, location and their permission to be put forward to this client.
  5. Check whether the candidate has already applied to the client directly or through another agency. Duplicate submissions damage trust on all sides.

Consistent screening is what lets you defend a shortlist when a client asks why a candidate is on it. The guide on screening CVs against requirements gives a method that works for any role. In Spark Careers Enterprise, agencies keep each client in its own workspace so jobs, candidates and notes stay separate, and every CV gets a fit score against the job's requirements with the matched and missing skills listed.

Submit a shortlist clients can act on

A good submission saves the hiring manager time. A weak one sends them back to the job boards, and sometimes to another agency.

  • Send a short, strong shortlist rather than every CV that passed screening.
  • For each candidate, write a brief summary: how they meet each must-have, what is missing, pay expectation, notice period and availability for interviews.
  • Use the same format for every submission to the same client so they can compare candidates side by side.
  • Leave out personal details the client does not need at this stage, in line with the data protection rules where you hire.
  • Agree a date for feedback when you submit, and follow up on that date.

If the client rejects most of a shortlist, do not simply send more CVs. Ask which must-have each rejected candidate missed, compare the answers with the job order and agree with the client whether the search or the brief needs to change. Then record the change in the job order so the whole desk works from the same version.

Run interviews and gather feedback

Once the client wants to meet a candidate, the agency usually coordinates. This is where much of the delay in a search builds up.

  • Offer the candidate interview times quickly and confirm in writing with the time, format, interviewers and anything to prepare.
  • Brief the candidate before each interview and debrief them straight after, while it is fresh.
  • Ask the client for structured feedback against the job order, not just yes or no. Suggest they use an interview scorecard so their feedback is comparable across candidates.
  • Pass feedback to every candidate, including those who are not moving forward.
  • Keep your record of each candidate's stage in step with the client's process, so you can tell anyone where a candidate stands at a glance.

Offer, placement and follow-up

  1. Before the offer, re-confirm the candidate's pay expectations, notice period and any other offers they are considering.
  2. Help the client make a clear written offer and handle the negotiation openly with both sides.
  3. Run reference checks if the client asks you to, using questions agreed with them in advance.
  4. Once the offer is accepted, stay in touch through the notice period. Counter-offers and second thoughts often surface in this window.
  5. Check in with both the candidate and the client after the start date, and again before the replacement period ends.
  6. Close the search with the outcome and notes, and keep strong runners-up in your database where they have agreed to it.

The close-out step is easy to skip when the next search is already waiting. Do it anyway. The notes you write today are what make the next search for the same client faster.

Agency workflow checklist

  • A written job order is confirmed by the client.
  • Feedback times are agreed before the first submission.
  • Every CV is screened against the same must-haves, with reasons recorded.
  • Candidate permission is recorded before each submission.
  • A duplicate check is done before each submission.
  • Every submission uses the same format.
  • Every candidate hears the outcome.
  • Follow-up dates are set for after the placement.

Your next hire, start to finish, in one place.

Free workspace. No card. Full scoring free for 7 days.