Screening and selection · 5 min read

How to run reference checks

Reference checks work best as a short, structured call that confirms what you learned in interviews and fills specific gaps. This guide covers consent, who to contact, what to ask and how to use the answers.

What reference checks are for

A reference check is a conversation with someone who has worked with your candidate. Done well, it confirms what you saw in interviews and fills one or two specific gaps. Done badly, it becomes a box-ticking call that tells you nothing, or a vague chat that lets one person's opinion outweigh everything else.

Use references to:

  • Confirm facts, such as job title, dates and main responsibilities.
  • Check specific areas the interviews left unclear, such as how the person handles a heavy workload.
  • Learn how to support the person well once they join.

Do not use references to re-run the whole interview, or as the main basis for a decision. By the time you check references, your structured interviews and scorecards should have done most of the work.

Before you call: consent, timing and who to ask

Always ask the candidate before you contact anyone. Explain who you will contact, what you will ask and how you will store the notes. Many people have not told their current employer they are looking, so contacting a current manager without permission can cause real harm.

Rules on references vary from place to place. Check the employment and data protection rules where you hire, including whether you need written consent, what you may ask, what referees may share and how long you may keep the notes.

On timing, most teams check references for the final one or two candidates, after interviews and before or alongside a conditional offer. Checking every applicant early wastes referees' time and the candidate's goodwill.

Ask the candidate for two or three referees and say what kind you want:

  • A recent direct manager, if possible.
  • A peer or someone from another team they worked with closely.
  • For people managers, someone who reported to them.
  • For people early in their career, a tutor, supervisor or volunteer coordinator.

Be flexible. Some employers only confirm dates and titles as a matter of policy. That tells you nothing about the candidate, so do not treat it as a warning sign.

Plan your questions

Write the questions down and ask every referee the same core set. Add one or two questions that follow up on gaps from the interviews. Avoid questions about health, family, age, religion or anything else unrelated to the job.

A sample set:

  1. How do you know the candidate, and for how long did you work together?
  2. What was their role, and what were they responsible for?
  3. What did they do especially well? Can you give an example?
  4. Where did they need the most support or development?
  5. How did they handle a time when priorities changed suddenly or work piled up?
  6. How did they work with colleagues who disagreed with them?
  7. What kind of manager or setting brings out their best work?
  8. Given the chance, would you work with them again? Why or why not?
  9. Is there anything else that would help them succeed in this role?

Questions that ask for examples get better answers than questions that invite a rating. 'Were they reliable?' invites a yes. 'Tell me about a deadline they were working towards' invites evidence.

Run the call step by step

  1. Book a time by email. Say who you are, the role, that the candidate gave permission and how long the call will take. Fifteen to twenty minutes is usually enough.
  2. Open by confirming the basics: how they know the candidate, their working relationship and the dates.
  3. Describe the role briefly so the referee can relate their answers to it.
  4. Ask your core questions in order. Ask for examples and let silences run. Referees often add the most useful detail after a pause.
  5. Ask your follow-up questions on the specific gaps from the interviews.
  6. Close by thanking them and confirming how their comments will be used.
  7. Write up your notes straight after the call, while the detail is fresh.

Written questionnaires are an option when a referee prefers them, but they usually produce shorter and more guarded answers than a call.

Read the answers fairly

Referees are human. Some are generous with everyone. Some are cautious by habit or by employer policy. Read the answers with that in mind.

  • Look for consistency. Do the examples match what the candidate told you and what you saw in the interviews and any work sample?
  • Weigh specific examples above general praise. 'Great team player' carries less weight than a story about how they helped a colleague through a hard week.
  • Treat faint praise or long hesitation as a prompt for a follow-up question, not as a verdict.
  • Do not let one negative comment outweigh strong evidence from your interviews. Ask whether it relates to the job and whether another referee confirms it.
  • Watch for bias. If a referee shares something unrelated to the job, leave it out of your notes and your decision. Our guide to reducing bias in hiring covers this in more depth.

If a reference raises a real concern, raise it with the candidate. Give them a chance to explain before you decide.

Record what you learn and use it

Keep reference notes short and factual. Note the referee, the date, their relationship to the candidate, and the answer to each question with any examples given. Store them with the rest of the hiring record, with access limited to the people involved in the decision. In Spark Careers Enterprise, reference notes can be added to the applicant's record on the pipeline board, alongside interview feedback, so the hiring team sees all the evidence in one place.

Share a summary with the hiring manager, then decide using everything you have, not the reference alone. Agree with the hiring manager in advance who makes the call if references and interviews point in different directions. If you do hire the person, the references also give their new manager a head start on how to support them.

Reference check checklist

  • Candidate consent obtained before any contact
  • Employment and data protection rules where you hire checked
  • References checked only for final candidates
  • Two or three referees, including a recent manager where possible
  • Same core questions for every referee
  • One or two follow-ups on gaps from the interviews
  • No questions unrelated to the job
  • Notes written straight after each call
  • Concerns raised with the candidate before deciding
  • Notes stored securely with limited access

Your next hire, start to finish, in one place.

Free workspace. No card. Full scoring free for 7 days.