Screening and selection · 5 min read
Work samples and skills tests
A good work sample shows how someone does the actual job, in a short task scored the same way for everyone. This guide covers when to use one, how to design it and how to score it fairly.
What counts as a work sample
A work sample asks a candidate to do a small piece of the real job. A skills test checks one specific skill on its own. Both give you direct evidence, which is more useful than a description of past work on a CV or an answer to a hypothetical question.
Common formats include:
- Work sample: a short task taken from the job, such as drafting a customer reply, reviewing a set of accounts or fixing a small bug.
- Job simulation: a role play or scenario, such as a mock sales call or handling an unhappy customer.
- Skills test: a focused check of one skill, such as a spreadsheet task, a proofreading exercise or a short coding problem.
- Take-home task: done in the candidate's own time, usually with a deadline.
- Live exercise: done during an interview, often with the candidate talking through their approach.
Avoid general puzzles, brain teasers and tests with no clear link to the job. They mostly measure how good someone is at puzzles, and candidates can tell.
Decide if you need one, and where it goes
Not every role needs a test. Use one when a core skill is hard to judge from a CV or an interview answer, and when you can design a task that is close to the real work. Writing, analysis, coding, design, sales and customer service roles are usually good fits.
Placement matters. A long task early in the process asks a lot of people who may never get an interview. A common pattern is:
- Screen CVs against the job requirements.
- Hold a short first conversation.
- Set the work sample for those still in the process.
- Use the final interview to discuss the work sample and cover other areas.
Plan this as a named stage in your hiring pipeline so everyone knows when it happens, who sets it and who scores it. In Spark Careers Enterprise, you can add the work sample as its own stage on the pipeline board, move applicants into it, and keep each reviewer's notes and feedback on the applicant's record.
Design the task step by step
- Pick one to three skills to test. Take them from your job requirements. A task that tries to test everything ends up testing nothing well.
- Base the task on real work. Think of something the person would do in their first month. Strip out anything confidential and simplify it.
- Set a realistic time limit. Decide how long a capable person would take, then tell candidates that figure. Keep take-home tasks short. If a task needs several hours, consider paying for the time or moving it to a live session.
- Write clear instructions. Say what to produce, what format to use, what tools are allowed, the deadline and how the work will be judged. Unclear instructions test guesswork, not skill.
- Write the scoring rubric before anyone takes the test. This stops you shaping the standard around the first submission you see.
- Try the task yourself or on a colleague. If it takes them far longer than the time limit, cut it down.
Examples by role
- Customer service representative: reply in writing to three customer messages of rising difficulty, using a short policy sheet you provide.
- Accountant or bookkeeper: reconcile a small set of sample transactions and list any errors found.
- Content writer: edit a weak short draft and write a headline and summary for it.
- Data analyst: answer three business questions from a sample dataset and explain the findings in a short note.
- Sales development representative: write a first outreach email to a described prospect, then role play a short call.
- Frontend developer: build or fix a small component from a written brief, within a set time.
- Project manager: turn a messy set of meeting notes into a plan with owners, dates and risks.
Role-specific question banks, such as our interview questions for 40 roles, are useful for the follow-up conversation about how the candidate approached the task.
Score it with a rubric
A rubric turns a judgement into a consistent score. For each skill you are testing, describe what weak, acceptable and strong work looks like. Here is a sample for the customer reply task:
- Accuracy (1 to 3): 1 gets the policy wrong; 2 is correct but misses a detail; 3 is fully correct and complete.
- Tone (1 to 3): 1 is curt or defensive; 2 is polite but generic; 3 is warm, clear and suited to the customer's mood.
- Clarity (1 to 3): 1 is hard to follow; 2 is clear but long; 3 is short, clear and easy to act on.
- Problem solving (1 to 3): 1 restates the problem; 2 offers a fix; 3 offers a fix and heads off the next question.
Then apply a few simple controls:
- Remove names from submissions before scoring where you can.
- Have two people score each submission independently, then compare.
- Score every submission against the rubric, not against the other submissions.
- Record the scores alongside your interview scorecard so the final decision uses all the evidence together.
Be fair to candidates
A skills test asks for candidates' time and effort. Treat that with respect, and the people you do not hire will still leave with a good view of how you work.
- Tell people about the test early, ideally in the job ad or first conversation, with the expected time.
- Never use a task to get real work done for free. Use sample or invented material.
- Offer adjustments for disability or other needs, such as extra time or a different format, and make it easy to ask.
- Give everyone the same task, instructions and time.
- Offer brief feedback, especially to people who completed the task but were not hired. Our guide to candidate feedback shows how to keep it short and useful.
- Check the employment and data protection rules where you hire, particularly before using formal psychometric or online assessments.
Work sample checklist
- A clear reason to test, linked to the job requirements
- One to three skills tested
- Task based on real, non-confidential work
- Time limit stated and tried on a colleague
- Instructions cover output, format, tools, deadline and judging
- Rubric written before the first submission
- Two independent scorers where possible
- Candidates told about the test early
- Adjustments offered
- Feedback offered to everyone who completed it
Your next hire, start to finish, in one place.
Free workspace. No card. Full scoring free for 7 days.