Interviews · 5 min read

Panel interviews: how to run them well

A panel interview puts several interviewers in one session with a candidate. This guide covers when to use one, who should sit on it, how to plan and run it, and how to reach a fair decision afterwards.

When a panel interview makes sense

A panel interview is one session where two or more interviewers meet a candidate together. Done well, it saves the candidate repeated trips or calls, gives several people the same evidence, and reduces the effect of any one interviewer's preferences. Done badly, it feels like an interrogation and produces a muddled decision.

Panels work best when:

  • The role works closely with several teams, and each needs a say.
  • You want to cut the number of separate interview rounds.
  • The decision needs more than one view, for example for leadership or senior specialist roles.
  • Candidates are travelling or taking time off work, and one longer session is kinder than three short ones.

For early screening, a one to one call is usually enough. Save the panel for the stage where you are choosing between strong candidates.

Choose the panel

Keep the panel to three people where possible, and no more than four. Each extra person adds questions, scheduling effort and pressure on the candidate. A typical panel includes:

  • The hiring manager, who leads on the core skills of the role.
  • A peer from the team, who leads on day to day work and collaboration.
  • Someone from a partner team or HR, who leads on behaviours and gives a second view.

Aim for a mix of backgrounds and perspectives. Make sure every panelist knows the job well enough to judge it. Someone added only to fill a seat tends to ask off topic questions. If the hiring manager and recruiter have not yet agreed what the role needs, sort that out first. Our guide to working with hiring managers covers how.

Plan the session before the day

Most panel problems come from poor planning. Name one person as the chair. About a week before the first session, the chair should:

  1. Agree the criteria for the role, taken from the job description.
  2. Split the criteria between panelists, so each person owns two or three areas and the questions for them. Nobody asks about everything.
  3. Write the questions and the order. Use the same set for every candidate, as in any structured interview.
  4. Prepare one scorecard per panelist per candidate.
  5. Send panelists the candidate's CV, the job description and their questions at least a day ahead.
  6. Tell the candidate who will be on the panel, their roles, the format and how long it will last.

Telling the candidate in advance costs nothing and reduces nerves. A candidate who walks into an unexpected room of strangers will not show you their best work. In Spark Careers Enterprise, you can send applicants a booking link so they pick an interview time themselves, which cuts down the emails needed to fix a panel slot.

Run the interview

The chair keeps time and keeps the session calm. A simple running order for a 60 minute panel:

  • 5 minutes: the chair welcomes the candidate, introduces each panelist and explains the format.
  • 40 minutes: each panelist asks their questions in the agreed order. The others listen and take notes.
  • 10 minutes: the candidate asks their own questions.
  • 5 minutes: the chair explains the next steps and closes.

A few habits make a big difference. Only one person asks at a time. Panelists do not interrupt each other or jump in with new topics. Everyone takes notes, not only the person asking, so the evidence is shared. Keep body language neutral, since a nervous candidate will read every frown and every glance between panelists.

The chair's opening sets the tone. A good opening tells the candidate that each panelist will ask about a different area, that people will be writing notes, and that it is fine to take a moment to think before answering. It also tells them when they will get their turn to ask questions. A candidate who knows the shape of the hour can focus on giving good answers instead of guessing what comes next.

For a panel held over video, agree in advance who shares a screen, who watches the time and what happens if a connection drops. Our guide to video interviews has more on this.

Score independently, then decide

The biggest risk in a panel is that the most senior or most confident person sets the verdict for everyone. To avoid this, each panelist completes their own scorecard straight after the session, before any discussion. Use an interview scorecard with clear anchors so the ratings mean the same thing to everyone.

Then meet briefly. The chair goes through the criteria one at a time, asking the most junior panelist to speak first so their view is heard before others shape it. Where scores differ, compare the evidence in the notes. Agree a decision and record the reasons in writing.

Keep the debrief short and focused. Fifteen to twenty minutes per candidate is usually enough if the scorecards are complete. If the panel cannot agree, do not settle the matter by the loudest voice or by rank. Note the specific open question, such as whether the candidate can manage a budget, and decide how to answer it: a short follow-up call, a reference check or a work sample. Then let the candidate know when to expect a decision.

Common problems and how to fix them

  • Panelists repeat each other's questions: assign question areas in advance and share the full list.
  • One panelist dominates: the chair holds them to their own questions and time.
  • The candidate seems overwhelmed: slow down, offer water or a short pause, and remind them there are no trick questions.
  • Nobody takes notes: make note taking part of every panelist's role, not only the chair's.
  • The debrief turns into a debate about personalities: bring it back to the criteria and the evidence.
  • Panelists arrive unprepared: send the pack earlier and ask each person to confirm they have read it.

Panel interview checklist

  • Three or four panelists, each with a clear role
  • A named chair who manages time and the running order
  • Criteria and questions split between panelists
  • The same questions and order for every candidate
  • Candidate told the panel names, format and length
  • Notes taken by every panelist
  • Independent scorecards completed before discussion
  • Decision and reasons recorded

Your next hire, start to finish, in one place.

Free workspace. No card. Full scoring free for 7 days.